One Hundred Thousand for Rubbish Art: A Review of Menanam Padi di Langit [Planting Rice in the Sky] by Puthut EA. Blog post by Wahyudin, January 2017
[…] Listen to the description of Bambang Bujono (Tempo, 11 January 1975): “Neither in the invitation to painters to participate in the 1974 Grand Indonesian Painting Exhibition nor in the guidelines for the judging panel for the exhibition can you find a section normally found in judging guidelines, namely that the decision of the judges can not be disputed.
Maybe for this reason, a dispute arose that took the form of the “1974 Black December Declaration” and the delivery of a condolence funeral wreath on behalf of the community to the Jakarta Arts Council for the “Death of Indonesian Painting”. This happened on the last night of 1974, on the closing night of the 1974 Art Festival at the Jakarta Arts Center (Taman Ismail Marzuki or TIM). About the last thing, the condolence wreath, it didn’t come off because the security guards at TIM were the ones who “accepted” the wreath and they then stored and locked it in the TIM Dance Studio.”
Compare this with the description of Miklouho-Maklai (1998: 36-37). “On 31 December 1974 during the Grand Indonesian Painting Exhibition which was held biennially at TIM, an incident occurred which marked the start of the New Art Movement. A protest against the judges which awarded prizes to a number of paintings expressed in the form of sending a condolence funeral wreath emblazoned with the words “With condolences for the death of our painting”.
The condolence wreath was sent on the last day of the exhibition, when the prizes were given to the winners of the competition traditionally accompanying the Biennial. This was intended to publicize their anger at the judges who only valued what the students regarded as “decorative and consumerist” painting. The protesters called themselves the “Black December” movement and it was also supported by the students from the Indonesian Academy of Visual Arts (ASRI).”
Look at this photograph:
[…] The first paragraph on page 69 says, “Apart from the wreath, there was also a manifesto written by the protesters, many names signed it, especially from Bandung, Jakarta and of course the five people from Yogya.”
The question is, who were the “five people from Yogya”? It’s very surprising that even with his overactive imagination, the writer of this book is unable to answer this question.
A short explanation on page 67 of the book makes it possible to speculate about the “five people from Yogya”. But the page only mentions four people, Bonyong, Harsono, Hardi, and Nanik Mirna. So who’s the person not mentioned? Because the answer is not provided in the book, we have to recall the historical facts about the Group of Five Young Yogya Painters.
As I mentioned earlier, according to Harsono (2013), the Group of Five Young Yogya Painters which formed in Yogyakarta in 1973 under the “guidance” of Fadjar Sidik (painter, STSRI “ASRI” lecturer, and member of the judging panel for the “Good Paintings” exhibition) was composed of five students from STSRI “ASRI” Yogyakarta, that is Bonyong Munni Ardhi, FX Harsono, Hardi, Nanik Mirna, and Siti Adiyati. (Also see Hendro Wiyanto, “FX Harsono dan Perkembangan Karyanya [1972-2009]” in Re: Petesi/Posisi FX Harsono, (2010: 41-187); Dermawan T (2013) and Miklouho-Maklai (1998: 33-34)).
At the 1974 Grand Indonesian Painting Exhibition or Jakarta Biennial I, they were invited to participate. Apart from them, listed in the catalog were five other STSRI “ASRI” students who were also invited, namely Nyoman Gunarsa, Ris Purwana, Suatmaji, Sudarisman and Subroto SM.
Given these historical facts, I hope no reader is tempted to speculate and answer that what was meant by the writer of this book by the “five people from Yogya” is Bonyong, Harsono, Hardi, Nanik Mirna, and Siti Adiyati, because such speculation would take one down the road of historical liars and the anti-“Jasmerah” brigade.
How could it be otherwise as you need to know that although invited to participate in the 1974 Grand Indonesian Painting Exhibition, there were only four members of the Group of Five Young Yogya Painters who signed the “Black December” manifesto, namely Bonyong, Hardi, Harsono, and Adiyati. (See Harsono (2013); Dermawan T. (2013); Wiyanto (2010: 70) and Miklouho-Maklai (1998: 36-38).) The one person who did not sign the Declaration, of course you can guess, was Nanik Mirna. This is why Nanik did not receive the academic sanction of being “suspended without time limit” from STSRI “ASRI” as was the case with Bonyong, Hardi, Harsono, Adiyati, and Ris Purwana. (See “Skors di ASRI”, Tempo, 15 February 1975; Dermawan T. (tt.: 135); Dermawan T. (2013); Miklouho-Maklai (1998: 38) and Dermawan T. (1979: 2).)
Black December 1974 Declaration
Recalling that over the past few years, artistic and cultural activities have been carried on without a clear cultural strategy, we have come to the conclusion that art and culture entrepreneurs do not display a shred of evidence of the slightest understanding of the most fundamental problems of our culture. This is an indication that for some time the development of art and culture has been destroyed by a spiritual erosion.
For this reason, we feel the need in this black December of 1974 to declare our opinion regarding the symptoms visible in the works of Indonesian painting today.
1. That while the diversity of Indonesian painting constitutes an undeniable fact, even so this diversity does not in itself display positive development.
2. That for development that ensures the continuation of our culture, painters have a high calling to provide spiritual direction which is based on humanitarian values and which is oriented around the reality of social life, and which is oriented towards the realities of social, cultural, political and economic life.
3. That creativity is the essential nature of painters who employ whatever means to achieve new perspectives for Indonesian painting.
4. That therefore the identity of Indonesian painting has of itself a clear existence.
5. That what has hindered the development of Indonesian painting to date is worn out concepts which are still professed by the establishment, art and culture entrepreneurs and established artists.
In the interest of saving our painting, now is the right time for us to bestow an honor on that establishment, that is the honor of being a retired culture fighter.
Indonesia, 31 December 1974
Images of the Declaration come from Desember Hitam, GSRB Dan Kontemporer.
Image of Garuda by Kanva Abas from Fase Perkembangan Sejarah Senirupa Indonesia Bagian 2.